CJEU, UPC & Germany
SEP / FRAND Case Law
Court of Justice of the European Union
Huawei Tech. vs. ZTE Corp
July 2015
Case No. C-170/13
Article 102 TFEU - Undertaking holding a patent essential to a standard which has given a commitment, to the standardisation body, to grant third parties a licence for that patent on FRAND terms. ...
Click Here
Unified Patent Court
Mannheim Local Chamber Court
Panasonic vs. Oppo & OROPE Germany
November 2024
Unified Patent Court
Munich Local Chamber Court
Huawei vs. Netgear
December 2024
Regional Court München
WiFi 6 standard related
December 2023
Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe
RACH Related
October 2023
Regional Court München
Video Encoding
September 2023
7 O 1971/22
14.09.2023. European Patent No. 3 611 989. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court München
Anti Suit Injunction
July 2023
7 O 5416/23
Anti suit injunction standards in Germany. 20.07.2023, To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court München
Negotiation conduct related
April 2023
21 O 1910/22
Lack of willingness in licensing negotiations.19.04.2023, To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court Mannheim
Confidentiality Order Related
April 2023
7 O 91/22
Confidentiality order related. 14.04.2023, – To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Federal Court of Justice
Bundesgerichtshof
Exhaustion of Rights
January 2023
X ZR 123/20 – CQI-Bericht II
Determination of rights exhausted by placing patented product in the market .24.01.2023. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court München
Disproprotionality in FRAND
August 2022
21 O 11522/21
Disproportionality assessment in FRAND cases. 05.08.2022. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf
Anti Suit Injunction | HEVC
February 2022
2 U 25/21
Anti-Suit Injunction. HEVC Standard .07.02.2022, To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe
WIlling Licensee
February 2022
6 U 149/20
Determination of willing licensee. Delay tactics. 02.02.2022. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court München
Anti Suit Injunctions
February 2021
7 O 14276/20
25.02.2021. Anti-Suit-Injunction. Infringer in China
To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe
Determination of Willing Licensee
February 2021
6 U 130/20
Determination of a willing licensee.12.02.2021. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe
FRAND Negotiations
December 2020
6 U 103/19
Steps of negotiations. On appeal. 09.12.2020. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Regional Court of Düsseldorf
Article 102 TFEU
November 2020
4c O 17/19
Art. 102 TFEU. Def. is vehicle manufacturer. 26.11.2020. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Federal Court of Justice
Bundesgerichtshof
FRAND Negotiations
November 2020
Regional Court of Mannheim
Willingness | Value Chain
November 2020
2 O 34/19
Willingness of user to license in value chain. 18.08.2020. To read machine translated decision,
Click Here
Federal Court of Justice
Bundesgerichtshof
TFEU 102(b)
May 2020
Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf
GSM | UMTS
March 2019
Federal Court of Justice
Bundesgerichtshof
Optical Disc
May 2009
Federal Court of Justice
Bundesgerichtshof
Restraints on competition
July 2004
KZR 40/02
What is restraint on competition. 13.07.2004, To read machine translated decision,
Click Here